Lobbying "seeking to undermine" Dodd-Frank conflict minerals legislation

Press release: Electronics companies’ responses to allegations that their industry associations undermine conflict minerals legislation, 1 Aug 2012, Business & Human Rights Resource Centre

(update re joint NGO statement urging companies to "break from US Chamber of Commerce", Jun 2012- scroll down)

In May 2012 we invited the companies and associations listed below to respond to an article by Global Witness, “Are electronics companies trying to have it both ways on conflict minerals legislation?

This article alleges that associations such as the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) “have been seeking to undermine the implementation of Dodd Frank 1502”.   Dodd Frank 1502 will require companies registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to carry out supply chain due diligence on any minerals sourced from Dem. Rep. of Congo or adjoining countries.  Such companies would also have to submit an audited report on the due diligence measures they have taken to the SEC, and to disclose this information publicly.  Global Witness argues that lobbying by The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and NAM has “hampered the completion of the law” and this has “serious implications for the population of eastern DRC”.

Business & Human Rights Resource Centre invited the following business associations and companies (who are members of these associations) to respond to the concerns raised:

U.S. Chamber of Commerce - declined to respond
National Association of Manufacturers response [PDF]
Dell response [DOC]
Intel - declined to respond specifically to this statement but pointed to their public position on this issue and to a blog by The Enough Project
IBM - declined to respond
Verizon response [DOC]
HP response [DOC]
Motorola Mobility response [DOC]
Microsoft response [DOC]
General Electric response [PDF]
Xerox - declined to respond
AT&T response [DOC] 
Ford -
declined to respond

Following this, the Enough Project issued a press release on 28 June 2012 praising Microsoft, General Electric, & Motorola Solutions for "breaking" with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce on conflict minerals.

NGOs call for companies to "break from US Chamber of Commerce" - June 2012

In June 2012 we invited the companies below to respond to a joint press release by the Conflict Free Campus Initiative, Congo Action Now, Earthworks, Enough Project, Global Witness, Jewish World Watch & STAND, "Electronics Companies Must Break from US Chamber on Conflict Minerals"

This press release calls on leading electronics and automotive companies to make public statements against the position taken by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce on conflict minerals.  Here are the companies' responses and non-responses:

Acer response [DOC]
AT&T - did not respond
Canon
- did not respond
Dell response
[DOC]
Ford - declined to respond
HP -
declined to respond
IBM - "IBM respectfully declined comment" and shared this link with their response: Political Expenditures and Public Policy Matters (see Trade and Industry Associations)
Intel response [DOC]
Motorola Mobility - declined to respond
Panasonic response [DOC]
RIM response [DOC]
Verizon
- did not respond
Xerox response
[PDF]

The SEC announced on 2 July that it would vote on rules to implement conflict minerals provisions on 22 August 2012.  For details on its vote adopting these rules, and responses from NGOs, companies and others, click here.

US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)

Harris [part of BMO Financial Group] Supports Red Cross Flood Relief Efforts in Pakistan, Sacramento Bee [USA], 25 Aug, 2010

PM appreciates Korean government, people for support, Associated Press of Pakistan, 25 Aug 2010
[refers to Daewoo, Doosan Heavy Industries, Express, K-Water, LG Electronics, Lotte, Poongasan, POSCO, Sambu Construction, Sammi-Daewoo, Samsung]

General Mills Foundation Donates $250,000 for Relief in Pakistan (press release), 24 Aug 2010

RBC donates $100000 to assist Pakistan flood victims (press release), 23 Aug 2010

Chinese company donates 1000 ton Rice for flood victims, The Nation [Pakistan], 23 Aug 2010
[refers to China Asia International Finance, Khadim Ali Shah Bukhari]

Western Union Commits $100,000 to Flood Relief Efforts in Pakistan (press release), 23 Aug 2010

Update: U.S. Response to Pakistan’s Flooding Disaster [scroll to ‘Private Sector Response’], U.S. Department of State, 23 Aug 2010
[refers to Abbott Labs, Agility Logistics, AgriTech, AT&T, Al-Bario Engineering, Becton Dickinson, Chevron Pakistan, Cisco Foundation, Coca-Cola Export Corporation & Coca-Cola Beverages Pakistan Ltd., DuPont, EMC, Environment Consultancies & Options, Feros Sons Laboratories, General Electric, Hadayat Sons, Johnson & Johnson, Kabani & Company,  Levi Strauss Pakistan, MDS Foods, Monsanto, Procter & Gamble, Pfizer Pakistan, Silver Star Enterprises, 3M, Visa, Wackenhut Pakistan (part of G4S)]

Rogers Communications donates funds and launches text-to-donate campaign to help with Pakistan flood relief efforts, Voice of Toronto, 20 Aug 2010

Businessmen directly helping flood victims, Aamir Shafaat Khan, Dawn [Pakistan], 19 Aug 2010
[refers to Getz Pharma, GlaxoSmithKline, Lakson Tobacco Company (part of Philip Morris), Sui Southern Gas]

P&G [Procter & Gamble] and World Vision Respond to Pakistan Flood - Over 50 Million Liters of Clean Water Provided for Flood Victims (press release), 17 Aug 2010

Get RSS feed of these results

Related stories and components

Company non-response
18 July 2012

AT&T did not respond to: Electronics companies must break from US Chamber on conflict minerals", say NGOs.

Read more

Company non-response
18 July 2012

Canon did not respond to: Electronics companies must break from US Chamber on conflict minerals", say NGOs.

Read more

Company non-response
18 July 2012

Ford did not respond to: Electronics companies must break from US Chamber on conflict minerals", say NGOs.

Read more

Company non-response
18 July 2012

Verizon did not respond to: Electronics companies must break from US Chamber on conflict minerals", say NGOs.

Read more

Company response
3 July 2012

Response by Intel: Global Witness, Enough Project & others call on electronics & automotive firms to make public statements against US Chamber of Commerce position on conflict minerals.

Read full response

Company response
1 July 2012

Response by IBM: Global Witness, Enough Project & others call on electronics & automotive firms to make public statements against US Chamber of Commerce position on conflict minerals.

Read full response

Article
1 July 2012

Responses re lobbying over Dodd Frank 1502 on conflict minerals

Author: compiled by Business & Human Rights Resource Centre

In May 2012…Global Witness [published]… “Are electronics companies trying to have it both ways on conflict minerals legislation?”…allege[ing] that…the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) “have been seeking to...

Read more

Company non-response
23 May 2012

Ford did not respond to: Concerns raised over companies trying to undermine implementation of the US Dodd Frank 1502 requiring companies to carry out supply chain due diligence on minerals sourced from Dem. Rep. of Congo or adjoining countries.

Read more

Company non-response
23 May 2012

IBM did not respond to: Concerns raised over companies trying to undermine implementation of the US Dodd Frank 1502 requiring companies to carry out supply chain due diligence on minerals sourced from Dem. Rep. of Congo or adjoining countries.

Read more

Company non-response
23 May 2012

Intel did not respond to: Concerns raised over companies trying to undermine implementation of the US Dodd Frank 1502 requiring companies to carry out supply chain due diligence on minerals sourced from Dem. Rep. of Congo or adjoining countries.

Read more